Evaluation for 5.1c
Materials provide opportunities for students to practice interpreting, evaluating, and responding to discipline-specific artistic works of other artists through activities and tasks that progressively increase in rigor and complexity over lessons and units within the course.
In unit 4, lesson 4.9, students interpret, evaluate, and respond to discipline-specific artistic works by other artists through structured activities across lessons and units with increasing rigor. Students use the four-step “describe, analyze, interpret, and evaluate” criticism protocol to examine a selected work of art, describing what they observe in the image, analyzing how the artist arranges visual elements within self-portraits, and interpreting the visual evidence to consider artistic intent and what the self-portraits communicate about the subjects. Finally, students evaluate the artwork and its context to develop an evidence-based critique of how effectively the artists express intended ideas or themes. This sequence allows students to apply learning from previous lessons 4.7, in which they explored how architectural structure includes a variety of forms, and 4.8, which promotes understanding of forms in landscape architecture. This content increased in rigor over lesson 1.1, in which students created a self-portrait depicting items they care about.
The unit 6 final review shows the progression of skills developed through the course. The art criticism process repeats as it occurs throughout—describe, analyze, interpret, and evaluate—as students critique a work by Anni Albers. Unit concepts include weaving, fiber arts, fabric design, fan making, paper traditions, form, function, pottery, papier-mâché, and decoration, which are more complex than unit 1 concepts of portrait, expression, pose, proportion, space, perspective, sculpture, and positive and negative shapes. Students also engage in a “Portfolio Review, Reflection, and Presentation,” which is evaluated with the provided rubric. To achieve a level 4 in this category, students must select artwork that is appropriate to the unit’s artistic concepts and provide “insightful explanation of fit between artworks and Big Ideas.”