HMH Math 180 Texas Grade 4 Suitability Report: Prohibitions Criteria
Supplemental Mathematics (English)
Publisher: Houghton Mifflin Harcourt
Supplemental Math, Grade 4 (IMRA25)
Program: HMH Math 180 Texas Grade 4
Every introduction to each block of Math180 features controversial Liberal Supreme Court Judge Sandra Sotomeyer only. No conservative judges are ever features. This repeated exposure appears to be political bias and persuasion. This violates parental authority.
"The publisher will remove the Getting Started: First Two Weeks activity that appears on Ed in the View Resources tab under Addition, Subtraction, and Place Value.
The publisher will remove the Getting Started: First Two Weeks activity that appears on pages 5A-5O from the student Multiplication and Division mSpace.
The publisher will remove the Getting Started: First Two Weeks activity that appears on pages 5A-5O from the student Fractions mSpace.
The publisher will remove the Getting Started: First Two Weeks activity that appears on pages 5A-5O from the student Decimals and Integers mSpace.
The publisher will remove the Getting Started: First Two Weeks activity that appears on pages 5A-5O from the student Rates and Ratios mSpace.
The publisher will remove the Getting Started: First Two Weeks activity that appears on pages 5A-5O from the student Proportional and Linear Relationships mSpace.
The publisher will remove the Getting Started: First Two Weeks activity that appears on pages 5A-5O from the student Linear and Nonlinear Functions mSpace.
The publisher will remove the following resources from Ed. From the Discover page select All Resources tab, then click the Getting Started button under the Featured Categories.
Getting Started Guide: Getting Started Guide: Your First Two Weeks With Math 180
mSpace: Getting Started: First Two Weeks
mSpace Annotated: Getting Started: First Two Weeks
Teacher Display Tools: Getting Started: Your First Two Weeks - Day 1, Getting Started: Your First Two Weeks - Day 2, Getting Started: Your First Two Weeks - Day 3, Getting Started: Your First Two Weeks - Day 4, Getting Started: Your First Two Weeks - Day 5, Getting Started: Your First Two Weeks - Day 6, Getting Started: Your First Two Weeks - Day 7, Getting Started: Your First Two Weeks - Day 8, Getting Started: Your First Two Weeks - Day 9, Getting Started: Your First Two Weeks - Day 10
Hype up the fair
Thank you for your feedback.
The publisher will change the career focus of the Hype Up the Fair Simulation to Web Designer and remove any reference to Social Media. See list of changes at the link below.
File name: 7.1.2_Ex1_TXM180Full_Gr4_SUIT-0328
https://hmhco.box.com/s/z352vndx39fww98zntr20nz0n6bm2vbb
This activity is Common Core aligned because it requires students to apply fraction operations in a real-world context, use mathmatical reasoning to solve multi-step problems, and explain their thinking-all key components of the Common Core Standards. After logging into the program with the teacher login, click the series "Fractions", click block 2 "Fraction Relationship", open topic "Topic 1. On this resources page, there are 3 filters: audience, component, format- click component and filter "teaching guide"; it will then open up the teaching guide for the entire workbook. Strategies for Comparing Fraction". This unit titled "Doctor's Orders" to teach fractions alludes to organ donation specifically throughout the unit. on these specific pages. p. 58, 102-103; The use of organ donation as a context for math instruction in 4th grade does not align with the Texas Essential Knowledge and Skills (TEKS) for mathematics at this level. The TEKS for 4th-grade math focus on foundational skills such as number operations, measurement, data analysis, and geometry, all applied through concrete, age-appropriate, real-life scenarios. There is no standard within the 4th-grade math TEKS that supports or encourages instruction using medical or emotionally sensitive content such as organ donation.
Beyond the misalignment with academic standards, the topic of organ donation introduces complex emotional and ethical themes - such as serious illness, death, and surgical procedures- that are not suitable for the developmental stage of 9- to 10-year-old students. These are sensitive issues that can cause confusion or distress, particularly when students are asked to engage in role-play or decision-making related to life-and-death situations.
Instructional examples at this age should prioritize clarity, emotional safety, and relevance to students’ everyday experiences. Using familiar and neutral scenarios such as planning a class event, measuring for a project, or analyzing sports statistics - not only aligns with TEKS but also supports a positive, engaging learning environment. While it’s valuable to expose students to real-world applications of math, these should be carefully chosen to respect both their academic needs and their emotional readiness. The problem’s complexity and context, while real-world, introduces scenarios (organ transplant logistics) that may be too advanced or tangential for the targeted grade level, potentially overwhelming students rather than building foundational skills.
• The task’s reliance on extended data interpretation and optimization exceeds the intended depth of Measurement & Data standards, risking confusion rather than clarity in learning objectives.
• While the activity attempts to engage Mathematical Practices (MP1, MP4, MP5, MP6), its real-world context may distract from core procedural fluency and conceptual understanding emphasized in our curriculum, resulting in fragmented skill development.
This activity is Common Core aligned because it requires students to apply fraction operations in a real-world context, use mathmatical reasoning to solve multi-step problems, and explain their thinking-all key components of the Common Core Standards. After logging into the program with the teacher login, click the series "Fractions", click block 2 "Fraction Relationship", open topic "Topic 1. On this resources page, there are 3 filters: audience, component, format- click component and filter "teaching guide"; it will then open up the teaching guide for the entire workbook. Strategies for Comparing Fraction". This unit titled "Doctor's Orders" to teach fractions alludes to organ donation specifically throughout the unit. on these specific pages. p. 58, 102-103; The use of organ donation as a context for math instruction in 4th grade does not align with the Texas Essential Knowledge and Skills (TEKS) for mathematics at this level. The TEKS for 4th-grade math focus on foundational skills such as number operations, measurement, data analysis, and geometry, all applied through concrete, age-appropriate, real-life scenarios. There is no standard within the 4th-grade math TEKS that supports or encourages instruction using medical or emotionally sensitive content such as organ donation.
Beyond the misalignment with academic standards, the topic of organ donation introduces complex emotional and ethical themes - such as serious illness, death, and surgical procedures- that are not suitable for the developmental stage of 9- to 10-year-old students. These are sensitive issues that can cause confusion or distress, particularly when students are asked to engage in role-play or decision-making related to life-and-death situations.
Instructional examples at this age should prioritize clarity, emotional safety, and relevance to students’ everyday experiences. Using familiar and neutral scenarios such as planning a class event, measuring for a project, or analyzing sports statistics - not only aligns with TEKS but also supports a positive, engaging learning environment. While it’s valuable to expose students to real-world applications of math, these should be carefully chosen to respect both their academic needs and their emotional readiness. The problem’s complexity and context, while real-world, introduces scenarios (organ transplant logistics) that may be too advanced or tangential for the targeted grade level, potentially overwhelming students rather than building foundational skills.
• The task’s reliance on extended data interpretation and optimization exceeds the intended depth of Measurement & Data standards, risking confusion rather than clarity in learning objectives.
• While the activity attempts to engage Mathematical Practices (MP1, MP4, MP5, MP6), its real-world context may distract from core procedural fluency and conceptual understanding emphasized in our curriculum, resulting in fragmented skill development.
This activity is Common Core aligned because it requires students to apply fraction operations in a real-world context, use mathmatical reasoning to solve multi-step problems, and explain their thinking-all key components of the Common Core Standards. After logging into the program with the teacher login, click the series "Fractions", click block 2 "Fraction Relationship", open topic "Topic 1. On this resources page, there are 3 filters: audience, component, format- click component and filter "teaching guide"; it will then open up the teaching guide for the entire workbook. Strategies for Comparing Fraction". This unit titled "Doctor's Orders" to teach fractions alludes to organ donation specifically throughout the unit. on these specific pages. p. 58, 102-103; The use of organ donation as a context for math instruction in 4th grade does not align with the Texas Essential Knowledge and Skills (TEKS) for mathematics at this level. The TEKS for 4th-grade math focus on foundational skills such as number operations, measurement, data analysis, and geometry, all applied through concrete, age-appropriate, real-life scenarios. There is no standard within the 4th-grade math TEKS that supports or encourages instruction using medical or emotionally sensitive content such as organ donation.
Beyond the misalignment with academic standards, the topic of organ donation introduces complex emotional and ethical themes - such as serious illness, death, and surgical procedures- that are not suitable for the developmental stage of 9- to 10-year-old students. These are sensitive issues that can cause confusion or distress, particularly when students are asked to engage in role-play or decision-making related to life-and-death situations.
Instructional examples at this age should prioritize clarity, emotional safety, and relevance to students’ everyday experiences. Using familiar and neutral scenarios such as planning a class event, measuring for a project, or analyzing sports statistics - not only aligns with TEKS but also supports a positive, engaging learning environment. While it’s valuable to expose students to real-world applications of math, these should be carefully chosen to respect both their academic needs and their emotional readiness. The problem’s complexity and context, while real-world, introduces scenarios (organ transplant logistics) that may be too advanced or tangential for the targeted grade level, potentially overwhelming students rather than building foundational skills.
• The task’s reliance on extended data interpretation and optimization exceeds the intended depth of Measurement & Data standards, risking confusion rather than clarity in learning objectives.
• While the activity attempts to engage Mathematical Practices (MP1, MP4, MP5, MP6), its real-world context may distract from core procedural fluency and conceptual understanding emphasized in our curriculum, resulting in fragmented skill development.
Thank you for your feedback. The publisher will make multiple changes to the entire Fraction series, Block 2, Teaching Guide, mSpace, and related resources, as outlined in the document at the following link.
https://hmhco.box.com/s/5k3ufe0s0l6yzfzaat180o38xngb6dp0
*Please note: The Anchor Video for Fractions, Block 2, was replaced prior to submission, but before parallel changes could be made to the Teaching Guide, mSpace, and other related resources.
Located in the Math 180 / Fractions / Block 2: Fraction Relationships / Topic 2: Equivalent Fractions on a Number Line; RDI Boost Lesson 2B worksheet p. 2 the challenge question at the bottom left of the page asking the student : "A patient needs a blood transfusion after bladder surgery. The doctor replaces the lost blood using seven __1 4 -pint bags of blood. Draw a number line to find out how many pints of blood the doctor uses, and represent the amount as a mixed number. " The problem’s complexity and context, while real-world, introduces scenarios (organ transplant logistics) that may be too advanced or tangential for the targeted grade level, potentially overwhelming students rather than building foundational skills. Common Core Standards Addressed:
CCSS.MATH.CONTENT.4.NF.B.3
Understand a fraction a/b with a > 1 as a sum of fractions 1/b.
• (4.NF.B.3a) Understand addition of fractions as joining parts referring to the same whole.
• (4.NF.B.3b) Decompose a fraction into a sum of fractions with the same denominator in more than one way.
• (4.NF.B.3d) Solve word problems involving addition of fractions with like denominators, including use of visual fraction models and equations to represent the problem.
CCSS.MATH.CONTENT.4.NF.B.4
Apply and extend previous understandings of multiplication to multiply a fraction by a whole number.
• Understand a fraction a/b as a multiple of 1/b (e.g., 7 × 1/4 = 7/4).
CCSS.MATH.CONTENT.4.NF.A.2
Compare two fractions with the same numerator or the same denominator by reasoning about their size.
The task’s reliance on extended data interpretation and optimization exceeds the intended depth of Measurement & Data standards (4.MD.A.1, 4.MD.A.2), risking confusion rather than clarity in learning objectives.
While the activity attempts to engage Common Core, its real-world context may distract from core procedural fluency and conceptual understanding emphasized in our curriculum, resulting in fragmented skill development which can impede on learning.
the challenge question Located in the Math 180 / Fractions / Block 2: Fraction Relationships / Topic 2: Equivalent Fractions on a Number Line; RDI Boost Lesson 2B worksheet p. 2 the challenge question at the bottom left of the page asking the student : "A patient needs a blood transfusion after bladder surgery. The doctor replaces the lost blood using seven __1 4 -pint bags of blood. Draw a number line to find out how many pints of blood the doctor uses, and represent the amount as a mixed number. " The problem’s complexity and context, while real-world, introduces scenarios (organ transplant logistics) that may be too advanced or tangential for the targeted grade level, potentially overwhelming students rather than building foundational skills. Common Core Standards Addressed:
CCSS.MATH.CONTENT.4.NF.B.3
Understand a fraction a/b with a > 1 as a sum of fractions 1/b.
• (4.NF.B.3a) Understand addition of fractions as joining parts referring to the same whole.
• (4.NF.B.3b) Decompose a fraction into a sum of fractions with the same denominator in more than one way.
• (4.NF.B.3d) Solve word problems involving addition of fractions with like denominators, including use of visual fraction models and equations to represent the problem.
CCSS.MATH.CONTENT.4.NF.B.4
Apply and extend previous understandings of multiplication to multiply a fraction by a whole number.
• Understand a fraction a/b as a multiple of 1/b (e.g., 7 × 1/4 = 7/4).
CCSS.MATH.CONTENT.4.NF.A.2
Compare two fractions with the same numerator or the same denominator by reasoning about their size.
The task’s reliance on extended data interpretation and optimization exceeds the intended depth of Measurement & Data standards (4.MD.A.1, 4.MD.A.2), risking confusion rather than clarity in learning objectives.
While the activity attempts to engage Common Core, its real-world context may distract from core procedural fluency and conceptual understanding emphasized in our curriculum, resulting in fragmented skill development which can impede on learning. at the bottom left of the page
Located in the Math 180 / Fractions / Block 2: Fraction Relationships / Topic 2: Equivalent Fractions on a Number Line; RDI Boost Lesson 2B worksheet p. 2 the challenge question at the bottom left of the page asking the student : "A clinic separates a blood donation into platelets
and red blood cells. The donation is __11/20 platelets and __3/8 red blood cells. Does the donation contain more platelets or red blood cells?" The problem’s complexity and context, while real-world, introduces scenarios (organ transplant logistics) that may be too advanced or tangential for the targeted grade level, potentially overwhelming students rather than building foundational skills. Common Core Standards Addressed:
CCSS.MATH.CONTENT.4.NF.B.3
Understand a fraction a/b with a > 1 as a sum of fractions 1/b.
• (4.NF.B.3a) Understand addition of fractions as joining parts referring to the same whole.
• (4.NF.B.3b) Decompose a fraction into a sum of fractions with the same denominator in more than one way.
• (4.NF.B.3d) Solve word problems involving addition of fractions with like denominators, including use of visual fraction models and equations to represent the problem.
CCSS.MATH.CONTENT.4.NF.B.4
Apply and extend previous understandings of multiplication to multiply a fraction by a whole number.
• Understand a fraction a/b as a multiple of 1/b (e.g., 7 × 1/4 = 7/4).
CCSS.MATH.CONTENT.4.NF.A.2
Compare two fractions with the same numerator or the same denominator by reasoning about their size.
The task’s reliance on extended data interpretation and optimization exceeds the intended depth of Measurement & Data standards (4.MD.A.1, 4.MD.A.2), risking confusion rather than clarity in learning objectives.
While the activity attempts to engage Common Core, its real-world context may distract from core procedural fluency and conceptual understanding emphasized in our curriculum, resulting in fragmented skill development which can impede on learning.
"Thank you for your feedback.
The publisher will make the following changes to the mentioned RDI worksheets.
Original Text:
A patient needs a blood transfusion after bladder
surgery. The doctor replaces the lost blood using
seven __1/4 -pint bags of blood. Draw a number line to
find out how many pints of blood the doctor uses,
and represent the amount as a mixed number.
The doctor uses 1 and 3/4 pints of blood.
New text:
Layla is giving away travel-size lotion samples to her returning customers. Each sample contains 1/4 pint of lotion. If she gives away seven samples, how many pints of lotion has she used?
Draw a number line to find out how many pints of lotion Layla uses, and represent the amount as a mixed number.
Layla uses 1 and 3/4 pints of lotion.
In addition, the publisher will make multiple changes to the entire Fraction series, Block 2, Teaching Guide, mSpace, and related resources, as outlined in the document at the following link.
https://hmhco.box.com/s/jnvr3vemtsfsr1n8hplp0u3rpkgq5fvh
*Please note: The Anchor Video for Fractions, Block 2, was replaced prior to submission, but before parallel changes could be made to the Teaching Guide, mSpace, and other related resouces.
"
Block 1: Multiplicative Thinking < Explore Zone < Simulation "Hype Up The Fair"
Thank you for your feedback.
The publisher will change the career focus of the Hype Up the Fair Simulation to Web Designer. See list of changes at the link below.
File name: 7.1.2_Ex1_TXM180Full_Gr4_SUIT-0417
https://hmhco.box.com/s/whds6xpgt1gxn8271a5dyzwucia5hq4f
The publisher will edit the Anchor video to remove references to social media and homelessness. See list of changes at the link below.
File name: 7.1.2_Ex2_TXM180Full_Gr4_SUIT-0417
https://hmhco.box.com/s/r7yvl57ntrlreuv7cz85fza9kqgrmaax
The publisher will replace social media references throughout Multiplication and Division Block 1. See list of changes at the link below.
File name: 7.1.2_Ex3_TXM180Full_Gr4_SUIT-0417
https://hmhco.box.com/s/ltep1uuw2ao1cw9n50xcvifqxjcomltp
Anchor video and questions with heavy focus on using social media. Encourages Grade 4 students to use social media. This flag applies to ALL component versions of this section including Teacher, Annotated, etc.
Bottom left, continues refereance to social media and bloggers, how to use social media, careers online such as bloggers. This form clears out if I fill it out too long.
Questions revolving around bloggers, emails, digital careers, how to use social media, etc throughout this entire digital textbook. Grade4 students are not old enough to use social media platforms and most are restricted to age 12 and up. Grade 4 students are typically 9 or 10 years old. Children should not be encouraged to use social media throughout their math lessons.
Thank you for your feedback.
The publisher will edit the Anchor video to remove references to social media and homelessness. See list of changes at the link below.
File name: 7.1.2_Ex1_M180Full_Gr3-5_SUIT-0753
https://hmhco.box.com/s/x6jpx8n2zyuzfdrmc46lqujewqkosfnw
The publisher will replace all social media references throughout the Multiplication and Division, Block 1. See list of changes at the links below.
File name: 7.1.2_Ex2_M180Full_Gr3-5_SUIT-0753
https://hmhco.box.com/s/zmrvb5s0lyw6fhfrxj9b86t5eshgbdml
The publisher will change the career focus of the Hype Up the Fair Simulation to Web Designer. See list of changes at the link below.
File name: 7.1.2_Ex3_M180Full_Gr3-5_SUIT-0753
https://hmhco.box.com/s/b0mum2v4fwubj815sgi9ugdhesc5z8yt
The curriculum does not focus on mathematical process fluency, rather a very conceptual form of math using ‘full in the blanks’, drag and drop pictures, the use of a calculator embedded into the student platform on every questions, multiple choice answers provided. Students can click through the entire course without performing any mathematical processes, equations, standard algorithm. 100% Common Core digital math
Entire course provides embedded audio, digital calculator which violates TEKS 111.6(a)(3), this curriculum is conceptual math (common core) vs mathematical procedural fluency (Texas TEKS) , focus on global issues and digital usage. Does not encourage mathematical fluency, mathematical process, TEKS 111.6 (a)(4)
Heavy focus throughout on Common Core principles of conceptualizing math and representing math expressions rather than a heavy focus of actually performing math equations using mathematical process standards outlined in TEKS. This entire course can be done without reading or writing as the Student digital platform reads every sentence to students, includes digital calculator, includes multiple choice answers that student can click on until they randomly select the correct one, students can drag and drop objects until the correct ones are chosen without doing any math to progress to the next lesson online. No procedural standard algorithm is taught or used in this entire course. Mathematical fluency will not improve with this course.
Thank you for your feedback. The publisher has equipped the student application with teacher-controlled calculator that can be made available to students who require the accommodation. The publisher will remove any Common Core references or language throughout the program, platform help, and professional learning resources as indicated in the publishers detailed responses. The publisher will add teacher controlled text-to-speech availability and Spanish/English toggle availability to address reading avoidance.
Anchor video and description relates to a teenager getting a heart transplant and could be traumatic for 9 year old students.
Prior to the IMRA submission, the Anchor Video for Fractions Block 2 was changed to focus on fractional flow reserve of blood in a normal artery and in a narrowed artery to decide how best to help each patient. The video omits dramatization and focuses on the comparison of blood flow through arteries, without reference to severity of artery narrowing or blockages. We believe this change removes introduction to complex emotional themes.
To view this video, please log in using provided credentials and click link below.
https://www.hmhco.com/ui/#/discover/M180_EN_2022/connected-view
Follow this click path:
Math 180 (button at center of screen) > Fractions > Anchor Video > Have a Heart
The publisher will make the following changes to the student Fractions mSpace pages 58-59 related to this Anchor Video:
Publisher will change the text in the green circle.
Original text: This Anchor Video shows how a heart transplant team coordinates treatment for patients.
New text: This anchor video shows how doctors compare fractions to determine the treatment for patients.
Whole page, Organ Transplant game, matching and transporting organs to recipient locations. Not age appropriate for Grade 4.
The publisher will replace the Performance task activity on Fractions mSpace pages 102 and 103. Proposed changes are detailed in the following link:
Intro video encouraging and praising Social Media.
The publisher will edit the Anchor video to remove references to social media and homelessness. See list of changes at the link below.
File name: 7.1.2_Ex1_TXM180Full_Gr4_SUIT-0767
https://hmhco.box.com/s/0nq88t8kqqo61ufyelgxjfrqrnkpy32j
The publisher will replace social media references throughout Multiplication and Division Block 1. See list of changes at the link below.
File name: 7.1.2_Ex2_TXM180Full_Gr4_SUIT-0767
https://hmhco.box.com/s/rdzhzf2xopzt7ryemigrdrimq39dhp6i