Instructional Materials Review and Approval

Feedback Report

Displaying 1 - 22 of 22

English Language Arts and Reading - Phonics


Publisher: Essential Skills

ELAR, Phonics, Grade 1 (IMRA25)

Program: Super Phonics, Grade 1
Component: N/A (ISBN: N/A)
Reported Feedback ID 14503836:

Provide the verbal modeling of the word that you are having the learner identify so that they are not only viewing the word, but also hearing the correct pronunciation of the word.

Page Number: "Click on the word that matches the big word"
Location:

Word Match

Publisher Response: Pending Publisher Response
Pending Publisher Response
Response Submitted:
Response Updated:
 
Reported Feedback ID 14496531:

It would be beneficial to learners to see the direction in a written format throughout the grade one program.

Page Number: All grade 1
Location:

Directions throughout the entire grade one program.

Publisher Response: Pending Publisher Response
Pending Publisher Response
Response Submitted:
Response Updated:
 
Reported Feedback ID 14496526:

In this section the name of the letter is provided, but the learner is only expected to repeat the letter and there is no phonemic learning that is taking place. For first grade, this does not seem to be developmentally appropriate for the level of learning that the student should be experiencing.

Page Number: Alphabet - letter match
Location:

Letter match - part 1

Publisher Response: Pending Publisher Response
Pending Publisher Response
Response Submitted:
Response Updated:
 
Reported Feedback ID 14348521:

See and Match has the word "Vim" for the letter v. I would recommend using a word more familiar to a six year old.

Page Number: Beginning Sounds
Location:

K Qu V X Y Z

Publisher Response: Pending Publisher Response
Pending Publisher Response
Response Submitted:
Response Updated:
 
Reported Feedback ID 14496601:

Letter sound that is stated when the learner clicks on the first letter should be repeated throughout the activity as we as the name of the letter.

Page Number: Grade 1 - learn the Consonants -Common Reversals
Location:

Common reversal activity

Publisher Response: Pending Publisher Response
Pending Publisher Response
Response Submitted:
Response Updated:
 
Reported Feedback ID 14503841:

Instructions are unclear for the learner when the developer says to click on the letters that will make a word with the word family, but it is unclear of how the letters are being blended together.

Page Number: Grade 1: Short Vowels
Location:

Short vowels: Word Families

Publisher Response: Pending Publisher Response
Pending Publisher Response
Response Submitted:
Response Updated:
 
Reported Feedback ID 14503851:

Throughout the entire program the author should pronounce the words so that the learner is able to hear the words pronounced properly before they are prompted to follow any directives. Hearing the word will aid the learner in blending the letter sounds.

Page Number: Long Vowels
Location:

Long Vowels

Publisher Response: Pending Publisher Response
Pending Publisher Response
Response Submitted:
Response Updated:
 
Reported Feedback ID 14441091:

Spelling Bee - The word "meat" is said by the instructor, but I typed "meet" and got it wrong. If you use homophones, then the instructor needs to use the word in a sentence to let the learner know which word they are wanting spelled.

Page Number: Long Vowels
Location:

Review

Publisher Response: Pending Publisher Response
Pending Publisher Response
Response Submitted:
Response Updated:
 
Reported Feedback ID 14350511:

The second activity in Sentences states gem already obtained after first try.

Page Number: Short i
Location:

Sentences

Publisher Response: Pending Publisher Response
Pending Publisher Response
Response Submitted:
Response Updated:
 
Reported Feedback ID 14437306:

After the second activity for Picture Match it states that the gem is already obtained.

Page Number: Short Vowels
Location:

Short u

Publisher Response: Pending Publisher Response
Pending Publisher Response
Response Submitted:
Response Updated:
 
Reported Feedback ID 14349781:

Word Match states that the gem was already obtained when it was the first attempt, and there were no errors.

Page Number: Short Vowels
Location:

Short e

Publisher Response: Pending Publisher Response
Pending Publisher Response
Response Submitted:
Response Updated:
 
Reported Feedback ID 14437381:

All the second activities in "Word Match, Flash Cards, Picture Match, and Sentences states that the gem has already been obtained when you complete the activity.

Page Number: Short Vowels
Location:

Review

Publisher Response: Pending Publisher Response
Pending Publisher Response
Response Submitted:
Response Updated:
 
Reported Feedback ID 14349901:

Shows gem already obtained after first attempt.

Page Number: Short Vowels
Location:

Short e - Picture Match

Publisher Response: Pending Publisher Response
Pending Publisher Response
Response Submitted:
Response Updated:
 
Reported Feedback ID 14351026:

After the second activity for Picture Match it states that the gem is already obtained.

Page Number: Short Vowels
Location:

Short o - Picture Match

Publisher Response: Pending Publisher Response
Pending Publisher Response
Response Submitted:
Response Updated:
 
Reported Feedback ID 14349546:

Flash Cards - The big words disappear too fast. If the learner is distracted, then they do not have a chance to see the word again.

Page Number: Short Vowels
Location:

Short a

Publisher Response: Pending Publisher Response
Pending Publisher Response
Response Submitted:
Response Updated:
 
Reported Feedback ID 14350376:

2nd part of Picture Match - States Gem already obtained after 1st try.

Page Number: Short Vowels
Location:

Short i

Publisher Response: Pending Publisher Response
Pending Publisher Response
Response Submitted:
Response Updated:
 
Reported Feedback ID 14437311:

Please choose another word instead of dumb to rhyme with. It can be confusing to the learner since it has the silent b at the end. See screenshot.

Page Number: Short Vowels
Location:

Short u - Rhyming Words

Publisher Response: Pending Publisher Response
Pending Publisher Response
Response Submitted:
Response Updated:
 
Reported Feedback ID 14349896:

Flash Cards - Shows gem already obtained, even though it was the first attempt. See screenshot.

Page Number: Short Vowels
Location:

Short e

Publisher Response: Pending Publisher Response
Pending Publisher Response
Response Submitted:
Response Updated:
 
Reported Feedback ID 14350881:

After the second activity in flash cards it states that gem has already been obtained.

Page Number: Short Vowels
Location:

Short o - Flash Cards

Publisher Response: Pending Publisher Response
Pending Publisher Response
Response Submitted:
Response Updated:
 
Reported Feedback ID 14350366:

Flash Cards - Gem already obtained after 1st attempt.

Page Number: Short Vowels
Location:

Short i

Publisher Response: Pending Publisher Response
Pending Publisher Response
Response Submitted:
Response Updated:
 
Reported Feedback ID 14503821:

Throughout this section the letter blending is not done so in a fluent manner to direct the learner to understand the formation of a word.

Page Number: Wordmaking
Location:

Beginning Sounds: BFMST/CDLPR/GHJNW/KqUvxyz

Publisher Response: Pending Publisher Response
Pending Publisher Response
Response Submitted:
Response Updated:
 
Component: Super Phonics (ISBN: N/A)
Reported Feedback ID 12254531:

Would recommend removing the listening ear, as that is listening vs decoding. If you remove the scaffold of hearing the spoken word, it requires decoding skills.

Page Number: 1
Location:

From the Phonemic Awareness main menu, navigate to "Digraph Phonemes", then "ch", then "Where is the ch Sound?".

Publisher Response: Pending Publisher Response
Pending Publisher Response
Response Submitted:
Response Updated:
 
Displaying 1 - 22 of 22
back to top