Evaluation for 3.3a
If designed to be static, materials include educator guidance on providing and incorporating linguistic accommodations for all levels of language proficiency [as defined by the English Language Proficiency Standards (ELPS)], which are designed to engage students in using increasingly more academic language.
The
1st Grade Cooperative Learning & ELPS Strategy Guide outlines all the cooperative learning strategies used in the program, explains their purposes, offers grouping suggestions for different mathematics proficiency levels and emergent bilingual (EB) levels, and provides instructions and guidance for educators. The guide also includes directions for students and linguistic accommodations for the five EB proficiency levels as defined in the ELPS. The “Accommodations by ELPS Levels” section gives guidance and prompts for Pre-Production, Beginning, Intermediate, High Intermediate, and Advanced students. For example, in “Strategy 1: Build & Compose Buddy (Place Value & Representing Numbers 1–120),” the materials suggest that students at the Pre-Production level demonstrate understanding of place value by manipulating base 10 blocks to match a target number and using visual supports while a partner models the correct number representation. At the Beginning level, students identify place value using simple words and sentence starters, such as naming the number of hundreds, tens, and ones, with support from a word bank. Students at the Intermediate level use sentence frames to describe the value of digits, represent numbers in expanded form, write place value representations, and explain their thinking aloud. At the High Intermediate level, students use academic vocabulary, such as
decompose,
expanded form, and
digit value, to explain how numbers can be broken apart into hundreds, tens, and ones and represented in different ways. Finally, at the Advanced level, students justify place value reasoning by explaining how base 10 blocks represent numbers, describing why decomposing and recomposing numbers do not change their value, and coaching peers through the process of converting standard form to expanded form.
Additionally, in “Strategy 2: Make-10 & Strip Diagram Storytellers (Addition & Subtraction Word Problems),” students at the Pre-Production level demonstrate an understanding of addition and subtraction word problems by using linking cubes and strip diagrams to physically model joining and separating actions after a partner’s verbal guidance. At the Beginning level, students identify key action words and quantities from a story problem, use a word bank for support, and complete simple sentence starters to determine whether to add or subtract. Students at the Intermediate level use sentence frames to explain how quantities change in a word problem, write matching equations, identify unknown numbers, and describe the mathematical process. At the High Intermediate level, students apply strategies, such as making a ten, and use academic vocabulary to explain whether a situation represents addition or subtraction and how equations remain balanced. Finally, at the Advanced level, students justify mathematical reasoning by explaining why equations are true, proving solutions with evidence from the word problem, and connecting the relationship between the whole and its parts using precise mathematical language.